Banjo-Saxo Orchestra of Harrisburg

Hersheypark has had many jazz orchestras and bands appear at the park throughout the years, especially between the 1910s to 1960s. One regularly scheduled resident performer for the first half of the 1920s was a group called Banjo-Saxo Orchestra of Harrisburg. The name of the band came from two of its prominent instruments, and they were a very popular Harrisburg jazz band, led by their drummer, Merlin C. Crawford. Here is a history of the Banjo-Saxo Orchestra of Harrisburg.

Sourbeer’s Dance Orchestra

The Banjo-Saxo Orchestra started out as F. Marian Sourbeer’s Dance Orchestra. This orchestra was established by F. Marian Sourbeer, Jr., sometime around 1914. They became popular in South Central Pennsylvania, playing for events at the Brunswick Hotel in Lancaster, Williams Grove near Mechanicsburg, Armory Hall in Lebanon, or regular shows at Winterdale Hall in Harrisburg. The band played for about five years, when it was announced that the Orchestra was moving in a new direction.

Merlin C. “Buzz” Crawford, manager

Advent of the Banjo-Saxo Orchestra

During the last week of February 1919, there was an announcement published in regional newspapers regarding the end of Sourbeer’s Dance Orchestra.

Published by a new band called the Banjo-Saxo Orchestra, managed by Merlin C. “Buzz” Crawford, the announcement stated that as of March 1, 1919 Sourbeer’s Orchestra would no longer exist and that it was replaced by the Banjo-Saxo Dance Orchestra. The announcement stated that it was retaining the same personnel as the original orchestra, but was not retaining Sourbeer, forcing the name to be changed from Sourbeer’s Dance Orchestra to the “Banjosaxo” Dance Orchestra – the word banjosaxo is a combination of banjo and saxophone. It’s not clear why Sourbeer, Jr., departed from the group.

The new Banjo-Saxo Orchestra played their first show on March 1, 1919, at Armory Hall in Lebanon, and their second show at Winterdale on March 4. By April, the name of the band had evolved from Banjosaxo Dance Orchestra to Banjo-Saxo Orchestra.

The band included the following musicians:

  • George Finney, piano
  • Marlin Byrd, saxophone
  • Julian Webster, saxophone
  • Herman Brady, banjo
  • Frank Bretz, trumpet
  • Jay Trimmer, trombone
  • Harry Bomgardner, bass
  • Merlin C. Crawford, traps and drums

Banjo-Saxo at Hersheypark

In the summer of 1919, Hersheypark contracted the Banjo-Saxo Orchestra to play every Wednesday and Saturday night. This was a widely commended, even from The Hershey Press (albeit the hometown paper, they weren’t often to comment on bands playing in the park). This was a shrewd move on the park’s part, especially since the band was only a few months old.

They were able to make this decision largely thanks to Crawford’s previous employment. According to his 1917 World War I draft card, Crawford was employed by “M.S. Hershey” as a musician. This meant that Crawford was working for one of the Hershey interests in town – the park, as they had their own house band for vaudeville and silent movie shows in Hershey Park Theatre.

Hersheypark advertisment for their Seventh Annual May Hop dance at Hershey Park Ball Room, in 1921.

They were often signed to play a run of shows in mid-to-late summer (July-August). The band was also signed to play at one or multiple seasonal holiday events (May Hop, Memorial Day, Fourth of July, or Labor Day).

In 1925, the Banjo-Saxo Orchestra played in the afternoon and evening of July 4, while John Philip Sousa and His Band played in the Hershey Convention Center on July 4 and 5.

The orchestra played at Hersheypark most years between 1919 and 1925.

Gennett connection

The band continued to play for about six years. In 1923, the orchestra released their first recorded music, through Gennett Phonograph Company. Sold for 75 cents ($11.35 in 2020 US dollars), the songs Dearest and When Will I Know were pressed on a 10-inch double-faced record produced By Gennett.

J. H. Troup’s in downtown Harrisburg promoting the sale of the Banjo-Saxo record, in 1923.

Better known as Gennett Records, this company was a well known record label that worked with artists such as Jelly Roll Morton, Duke Ellington, Gene Autry, and King Oliver’s Creole Jazz Band (the band also featured Louis Armstrong early in his career). Gennett is best remembered for their connections with early major talent in jazz; the height of the label’s popularity was in the 1920s.

The end of the Banjo-Saxo Orchestra

In 1926, the orchestra took on some new venues, all within the state of Ohio. This was their first time touring out-of-state, with the orchestra going to ball rooms in Akron and Columbus. One of their notable stops included playing at the ballroom at Coney Island Amusement Park. Coney Island evolved into Kings Island theme park in the late 60s (though a water park exists today on the park’s original site).

During their Ohio tour, the orchestra operated under several different names. Examples include Buzz Crawford’s Banjo-Saxo Orchestra, Buzz Crawford’s Orchestra, or Buzz Crawford’s Dance Band. The band likely did this to standardize their band name to what other acts at the time were using.

Crawford left the Orchestra in January 1927, joining Johnny Whitman’s Orchestra, which had been signed to play Saturday nights at the Penn-Harris in Harrisburg.

It was not uncommon to see Crawford’s first name misspelled. In addition to Melvin, it was frequently misspelled as Marvin and Marlin.

Very limited evidence shows that Crawford may have re-formed the Banjo-Saxo Orchestra in 1928, with the band formally adopting a new name: Merlin Crawford and His Orchestra. However, some of the band’s instruments were put up for sale in 1927. Furthermore, there isn’t any evidence that Crawford was signed to play any shows in 1928.

What is definitely known is that in 1929, Crawford and his wife left Harrisburg to live in Washington, D.C.. In 1931, Crawford would take part in another start up orchestra – the National Symphony Orchestra.

Banjo-Saxo’s music

No known copies of the Banjo-Saxo Orchestra’s lone release are currently available online. It is not known how many, if any, copies of the record exist. If you have a copy of their music, or any Banjo-Saxo Orchestra memorabilia, mention something about it in the comments.

Interested in supporting The Amusement Parkives? Click here to learn more.


5 thoughts on “Banjo-Saxo Orchestra of Harrisburg”

    1. Joey D'Agostino

      I emailed the above (Roberts) address, but I received no response. Clarence “Firp” Roberts was my accordion teacher–and the finest human being I would ever meet. Through him, I was privileged to meet Art Van Damme and Charlie Magnante. Though he knew I came from an uneducated, low-income family, he always encouraged me to “work it out.” When I was 11 or 12 years old, he told me that I would “do something great in music.” Even so, I did little to nothing in music. Until 1996. It was then that the floodgates opened. If anyone is interested in my musical ideas–the fruit of the inspiration of truly wonderful man–feel free to contact me at

  1. I have a slightly warped but otherwise mint copy of When Will I Know/Dearest. If you are interested, I. can send you a good quality dubbing of it but it will have to be on tape (cassette or open reel, since my rig is still analogue.

  2. Pingback: Merlin C. Crawford - The Amusement Parkives

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: